An honest difference of opinion with Mooncat_Blue has me thinking. Mooncat writes uplifting material, to the point where all her entries appear to be inspiring or uplifting in some way. She's very good at it, so please don't take this as a dig at her writing ability.
But a recent post of hers was about birds. "All birds ache to fly," she said, drawing obvious parallels between our landlocked hearts, mired in day-to-day concerns, and the graceful flight of birds, which echoes our our desire to be free and above these petty worries.
However, not all birds fly.
I know this is going to be taken as mindless literalism, and everybody hates a literalist, but hear me out. There is this sick compulsion in society to make everyone want to "excel." Everyone needs to achieve "great things" and "soar" and "be the best they can be," as defined strictly in terms of material consumption and conspicuous status. In the midst of this, reminding people that "all birds long to fly" when they cannot necessarily take any concrete steps to achieve the success this implies is more than a little unhelpful.
Some birds fly, I argued in her comments section, because they don't know any better. They have no other method of dealing with life. Thus, they fly, and then their hunting instinct or whatever takes over, and they feed. This is how they continue to live. Similarly there are those who succeed in society because they can make no other choice. Whether their parents were overbearing perfectionists, and they never broke free from this, whether they have abnormal competitive streaks, or whether they are just plain greedy, many social climbers at the "top" of society are not shining exemplars of humanity and helpfulness. Instead, they are simply very competent at doing work for which they get paid obscene amounts of money. They are the birds who fly not because they make a conscious decision to do so, or because it is inherently the nobler choice, but because that is how they are built. That is the way they are wired to get through life. That is not the way everyone is wired to get through life.
Making heroes and role models of them is extraordinarily unhelpful.
Similarly, inspiring someone to soar and rise above is a simplification that overlooks the complexities of life. Maybe they can't rise up. Maybe it wouldn't be best for them to rise up. Are Cambodians happy that Pol Pot rose up to be in charge of government? Are Chinese who lost their ancestral homes, family records, and relatives happy that Mao rose from his humble roots to be dictator for over a quarter century? Sometimes - let's face it - we don't want certain people to rise as high as they possibly can on the social ladder, because power in their hands spells disaster of epic proportions. Even if all birds want to fly, do we want all birds to fly?
I know many of you are throwing up your hands at this point and saying that there's nothing wrong with the simple sentiment that everyone should rise as high as possible. Encouraging everyone to do their best can't possibly be bad, can it? But it's precisely that kind of naive sentiment that I want to challenge. You have to take the good with the bad when you make decisions or when you encourage things. When you advocate something, you should do so with full knowledge of the disasters that you might bring as well as the glories that you might achieve. "I didn't know this would happen" is an answer that gets you out of trouble, but does nothing to fix problems.
Not all birds are fliers. Some belong on the ground. Some can never get up there. And some can get up there, but we don't want them up there.
Recent Comments