November 17, 2008

  • Worth Being Featured

    There is a blogring whose title is "Content WORTH being featured."

    This blogring has, as far as I can tell, blurry pictures of the cookies people baked and Proustian tales of their days with family members.  ("I woke up.  I brushed my teeth thinking of the great day to come.  Then we did this.  It was great.  Then we did this.  Then someone said . . . ")

    Now, I fully support your right to use your blog for whatever you want to post.  It's what makes blogging wonderful.  I do question, however, the universal interest factor of a discussion of how much cinnamon you put in this batch of cookies and what you did with the frosting, and how many leftovers you had and what kind of tupperware you like to put them in.  Don't get me wrong.  I like cookies.  I don't oppose domestic talk.  It's just, this is a little less "eye-opening mass entertainment" and a little more "I could get this by listening to old ladies talking in the supermarket."

    I don't ask for much, really.  I just think that if you're going to brag about how your entries are "WORTH being featured" you should try to put all your entries on a higher level.  I don't do so with all my entries, and therefore I don't claim any such thing - and the vast majority of my entries (99.75%) are not featured.  Imagine that on some random day John, Dan, or Natalia wander by your blog and see four pages of text about how cute your new dog is, or the random personality quirk that makes your daughter fidgety when you try to send her to bed, complete with detailed asides on genealogy ("I think it comes from Aunt Bea's side - you know that side of the family."  No, actually, I'm afraid I don't know, and neither will your readers if you get featured.) 

    Should this get you featured?  In your heart of hearts, can you honestly tell me that 5000 random strangers on the internet are all brimming with eagerness to hear about your mother's back pain or how your last batch of cookies went? 

    Yes, you say? 

    You must be one hell of a writer.

November 16, 2008

  • Closer

    I can't decide whether to dislike the new Naruto opening theme because it's sugary pop-punk, or to like it because of its truths about reality.

    Kireti koto wo ieru hodo nanimo dekichainai kedo

    "The more time you spend talking big, the less you get done."  It's quite true.

November 15, 2008

  • The Kitchen Heat

    We all hate baseless criticism.  Some of us hate well-founded criticism.  But how do you take literary criticism from a stranger?

    Is it rude to wander into someone's blog where they have posted something - fiction, poetry, and essay - and critique it?

    "If you can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen."  - Truman

    But is that a fair way to look at what might simply be online journals?

November 14, 2008

November 13, 2008

  • You think you know

    [02:20] huangm: Dating subjects seem to get you lots of comments though
    [02:20] huangm: if you are into that sort of thing
    [02:20] huangm: though of course I suppose your biggest success is the whole karaoke thing
    [02:21] moritheil: Yeah, people feel they can speak with authority on dating whereas they have not much to say about mereology.
    [02:21] moritheil: It's a fallacy; I just don't know which one.
    [02:21] huangm: it's because everybody thinks hey have some sort of experience
    [02:21] huangm: which gives them authority
    [02:21] moritheil: Yes.
    [02:21] moritheil: But we all have experience with chemistry and physics and anatomy, and are not experts.

November 12, 2008

  • The Character of Love

    Love is tyrannical.  Love tells us where to go, who to see, what to believe.  Love blinds our eyes to one thing and fixes them on another.  It tells us what to eat, what to wear, and even where to sleep at night and with whom.  Not only do we not object, we obey with cringing and trembling, afraid that the least negligence will earn us Love's disfavor.

    Love is divisive.  Friendships, associations, nations, families have all been destroyed by Love.  They have been cast out of hand and expended as nothing more than resources to achieve a means.  Religion or politics may part friends, and sometimes gold will incite betrayal among comrades, but only Love is as far-ranging in its utter destruction of every bond conceivable.  And while we fault a man for selling out his friends, we react with sympathy and pity if it occurs out of Love.

    Love is manipulative.  Love did not itself write, "all's fair in love and war," but the phrase was written by one who knew intimately the character of Love.  For people have cheated, stolen, killed, robbed, betrayed, slandered, and committed every sort of offense in the name of Love.  If we look at Love as some off-screen controller, we become terribly aware of how we are merely pawns in its hand.  No Machiavelli, no Cleopatra, could deal as coldly and ruthlessly with people as Love does.

    So why do we put up with it?  If Love were a single citizen, it would be the enemy of every state that has ever existed.  If Love were a military official, it would be on trial at the Hague for crimes against humanity.  If it were a politician, it would be impeached, and burned in effigy in the streets.

    Rise up against Love, my brothers and sisters!  You have only your chains to lose.

November 11, 2008

  • CCF Speaks Out

    I previously reported that a Christian childrens' fund rejected nearly $20,000 that was donated to charity in memory of Gary Gygax.  Now in the wake of several thousand emails' worth of bad publicity, the fund has issued a statement:

    "This decision was in no way intended to be a reflection on Mr. Gygax, gaming enthusiasts or the game Dungeon and Dragons. We have the utmost respect for the gaming community and were touched by the generosity expressed through your auction."

    Does this settle everything?  On the one hand, certainly the motives behind the fund not accepting the money are not entirely clarified by this message.  On the other, the main issue is whether or not this is an issue pertaining to the demonization of gaming, and this pretty clearly states that it is not.

November 10, 2008

November 9, 2008

  • Humorless Liberals

    Humour and identity seem to be on peoples' minds these days.  Trunthepaige pointed out a recent study that suggests that (in her words) "progressives can't take a joke."  I submit that generally, what makes one progressive in the first place is the feeling that there is something wrong with society that needs to be fixed.  It would be strange for that to make one happy, so it may well be true that they are less likely to show amusement.  I see consistency in this, while Paige sees "an excuse for being a stick in the mud."

    What's the flip side of the coin?  People may reflexively claim that offensive behavior is humor because they really aren't "like that."  (Case in point: a recent incident involved a boss writing "KKK" and other white-supremacy-related notes on signs and employee time sheets, and then attempting to pass them off as a harmless joke.)  Let's assume for a minute that they really were intended as harmless jokes.  Is it the insensitivity of the one making the jokes, or the sensitivity of the ones who get offended that is the problem?  What is a reasonable expectation in a public environment or in the workplace?

    Where is the norm, the happy middle?  Maybe there isn't one.  Certainly there are a lot of thin-skinned liberals who are "bleeding hearts;" the stereotype does exist for a reason.  And just as certainly there are some thick-skinned conservatives that would not react unfavorably to the mention of organizations that carry on campaigns of fear and terror.  But consider that the reverse is true: there are also thick-skinned liberal pundits, and there are conservatives who are furious when their heroes are insulted in the slightest degree.

    So we come, ultimately, to the lesser of two evils: would you rather have a society where people get worked up a bit too often, or one where insensitive things occurred and people never got worked up over them at all?

November 8, 2008