December 7, 2008

  • Asking for it

    Statisticians will tell you that correlation never by itself implies causality.  Sciforums.com had an exchange between several members on the use of the term "asking for it" as shorthand for "it is statistically more likely that . . . "

    Six pages in, Tiassa posted an inspired reply that I thought I would repost here in case any of us are confused about the difference between statistics and causality, as it pertains to rape.  To set the stage, another member has just suggested that there is no real difference between saying a girl "was asking for it" and "was engaging in behavior that increased the likelihood of her being assaulted."  He suggested that a woman should cover up in public just as she would when eating a lobster.  Here is the response:

    The thing is that a woman is not a car, and a man is not the weather. The car does not get the random urge to get up and go dancing. The weather does not single out anyone to rain on. And . . . the lobster is dead. If it squirts you when you crack it open, I can promise you the thing wasn't thinking, "He's not wearing a bib! He wants me to squirt my hot stuff all over him!"

    I personally would take a different tack in explaining this, and approach it from the angle of rights. Either a woman does have the freedom to dress as she chooses, or she does not.  In modern societies we tend to be proud of the fact that people can say virtually anything and wear virtually anything.  Now, if she has total freedom to dress as she chooses, then we cannot turn around and say that dressing provocatively means she was "asking for it" and that sexual assault is an acceptable punishment.  Failure to defend her simply because she was dressed for a hot date is tantamount to saying she doesn't really have the right to dress as she pleases.  In fact, we have a term for that: extrajudicial punishment.

    Does the metaphor break down?  The freedom we speak of is not complete.  "You can't yell 'fire' in a crowded theater," as the saying goes.  But here again the legal punishment for the equivalent act already exists and is very specific: public indecency statutes call for police to arrest offenders, cover them up, cite and/or fine them, and transport them out of sight.  By no means is state-sanctioned rape part of this.  Accepting anything more extreme as punishment is counter to the rule of law - a topic that ironically tends to be very near and dear to those who tend to use language such as "asking for it."

    Let us consider two different decency violations.  If a male student streaking naked in celebration of some college event were to be accosted by a man and brutally raped, it would be on every major news channel.  Our nation would rise up in shock and horror, and there would be demands that the "immoral homosexuals" be purged from among us.  But if - when - a female student is brutally raped while wearing skimpy clothing to some college event, the same national level of outrage does not manifest towards all rapists.  They are all violations of the law, but the questions bear asking: why do we not see rapists dragged behind trucks until they fall apart, or tied to a fence and beaten until unrecognizable? Where are the calls for a great purge of rapists, the vast rallies against them, the "stay strong with sports" bulletin boards?  Where are the pastors thundering intolerance, hatred, and brimstone from the pulpit at them?  Does the issue not merit at least equal screen time? 

    I would think, as it is a far more widespread issue, it requires more attention - and yet we are so accepting of rape that we ignore it, or even blame the victim.  Rape is so commonplace that it does not occasion surprise or comment.  Does this not bother people?  Does it only matter when our daughters, our mothers, our sisters, our friends or lovers are in danger?  Let me pull something relevant out that is statistically valid: people who have committed sexual violence will commit it again.  This is true whether they are targeting women, men, or children.  You want to protect your loved ones? 

    "Put the evil away from among you."

December 6, 2008

  • Mumbai

    I haven't blogged on the Mumbai terror attack because I didn't know how to succintly summarize my feelings.  Oddly enough, one image did it for me:

    I doubt anyone will mistake it, but that is the Taj Mahal Palace Hotel burning.

    This pisses me off.

    That building was constructed to be a thing of beauty.  It was constructed as a symbol of the vibrancy of India, and to look at it was to be confronted with the fact that man is willing to spend large amounts of resources and effort in the pursuit of beauty.  It was, in short, proof that beauty has meaning.

    For me, there was a visceral reaction to the fact that this building was in flames.  The New York World Trade Center buildings were in flames.  The Bosnian Parliament was in flames.  When we see a building in flames we see ruin.  It is the hallmark of chaos, of the failure of peace and order, and it is a potent symbol for destruction.

    People who destroy beauty anger me, because beauty is what makes life worth living.  To destroy both life and the joy of life - no matter how much you worship the Creator with your lips, that is evil. It must be excised.

    Rant's over.  Go read up on strange synchronicity in the Mumbai attacks.  Some of that is hokey, but some of it is chillingly real.

December 5, 2008

  • Gold Standard

    My phrasing was admittedly a little odd on my last entry: I think we should focus more on the miracle that two people fall in love and say, hey, let's get together to the exclusion of all else.  That is - to be blunt - absurd and unnatural and illogical, even childish.  And yet we do it.  We aren't perfect at it by any means, but that we even try is astounding.

    There are reasons for my imprecision, but they are not likely to be communicated here, and that gets into something I would like to talk about.  I have noticed that familiarity in interpersonal relationships comes in degrees.  It is a bit like a subscription service to a "pay for content" game: varying degrees of revelation at the cost of increasing expenditure (of time, in this case, rather than money, but the metaphor holds.)

    That immediately tells me this: most people have not expended the time and thus do not care.  And that is really okay.  That is good and healthy and sane.  Imagine if the whole world wanted to know what you ate for breakfast.  I'm sure that my response to that would not be, "Hurrah, I'm famous," but rather "The world has gone utterly mad!"

    I previously blogged about sexual power and how one of the main problems in peoples' relationships with sex is that they refuse to pay for things they want.  Failure to pay for what you want is a broad issue, but in this case, I refer to conceptual things.  The example that I brought up was that of someone who wanted to indulge in debauchery while keeping a pristine "good girl" image.  Well, whoever said you can't have it both ways was technically inaccurate: you actually can have it both ways in cases like these, only it tends to not be worth it.  By carrying on long-term deceptions we deny some parts of ourselves.  The cost resurfaces elsewhere: added stress, bitterness, guilt, and rage then become the price paid for carrying on in secret.

    To someone asking me now whether or not they should carry something on in secret, I would say: You do not want it enough.  There is a king who gave up his throne for the love of his life (by all reports, he was not the love of her life, but still, he seemed quite happy.)  There are countless tales of people giving their all, even their lives, for the ones they love.  Sometimes these are blood relations, sometimes friends or lovers, and in a rare few cases the beneficiaries are even complete strangers.  I hold that these sacrifices were made not by people blind to the truth, but rather by people who were able to grasp with true clarity what their priorities were, and act accordingly.

    Great things sometimes require sacrifices.  If you come to a point where you cannot sacrifice what is required to make things happen, you must ask yourself: what are my priorities? Is this really so great?

December 4, 2008

December 3, 2008

December 2, 2008

December 1, 2008

  • Praan

    Bhulbona ar shohojete
    Shei praan e mon uthbe mete
    Mrittu majhe dhaka ache
    je ontohin praan

    Bojre tomar baje bashi
    She ki shohoj gaan
    Shei shurete jagbo ami

    Shei jhor jeno shoi anonde
    Chittobinar taare
    Shotto-shundu dosh digonto
    Nachao je jhonkare!

    - Rabindranath Tagore

    'Praan' is a musical adaptation of 'Gitanjali,' a Bengali poem about the oneness of life.  (Thanks to GuardianArchon for showing it to me.)

    The thing that really gets me is that it's by Garry Schyman, who also is responsible for the soundtracks Destroy All Humans and Destroy All Humans 2.  How does that work? How do you go from profound World music to imitation B-movie soundtracks?

    Well, I guess it pays the rent.

    Listen to a clip of 'Praan' here.

November 30, 2008

  • Numbers Game

    Okay, I just had to share this.  It's an old blog post from 2005, written by a software consultant:

    "Here's a funny story: About three years ago a young woman decided to track her sex life with [our] datablogging service. She was using a Sex Log that tracked sex partner, intimacy rating, orgasm rating, who initiated, etc. And she decided to make it public. Of course, I immediately subscribed to it via RSS like any good horny geek would :)

    Over the course of a few months she blogged about having sex with quite a few people. Using our graphing component she created a pie chart of her partners and the number of times she had sex with them. It started out as a solid circle. Then it was cut in half when she found another sex partner. Then in thirds.

    Before I knew it her sex partner graph looked like a freakin' pizza pie... small slivers... she must have had fifteen partners inside of two months. "What a slut," I thought... and went on with my life. (After telling my RSS reader to check her feed every hour, instead of every day.)

    Then one day something special happened. She was writing about her sexual encounters over the last few months in a blog entry. Reviewing her graphs. Kind of a nostalgic piece. All of a sudden she says something to the effect of "oh my gosh, I just looked at my graph... I'm slutty!"

    After I pulled myself off the floor from laughing so hard, I realized that something special had happened. Of course she was slutty... I had noted as much a month before. Anybody who knew her probably knew she was slutty. But she didn't!

    She didn't know she was slutty!

    Until she tracked the data, graphed it and analyzed it. Datablogging had given this young woman insight into her life. For me this was a watershed moment in datablogging. It was proof-of-principle that datablogging can help us learn about ourselves in ways that other tools can't. Sure, she probably had an inkling as she dropped trow for that fifteenth guy that maybe she was slutty, but datablogging brought it into conscious focus for her... a graph representing her sluttyness... her slut factor."

    I note that the man . . .
     - immediately passes judgment
     - looks upon further developments as validations of his judgment
     - assumes that his technological solution is just what someone needs
     - assumes that one example is proof that normal people need this
     - discounts the example with humour

    There is, of course, a lot wrong with this blog post.

    Perhaps the most obvious problem comes with the assertion, "She didn't know she was slutty!"  The consultant takes this utterly at face value, but is that at all plausible?  I find it far more likely that she was in denial about her activity and blogging about it reminded her of just how much activity she had undertaken.  Perhaps it's not that she didn't know; it's that she was doing her best to ignore the evidence because to admit it would tell her something she would rather not learn about herself.  Self-discovery can be a scary process.  Rather than assume someone is incredibly dense, why not acknowledge that we put up complex, often maladaptive barriers to protect ourselves?

    Assuming objective "sluttiness" exists, is sluttiness about numbers, or is it about intent?  Is it about actions given circumstances or is it just about events, with no concern for the circumstances?  Would a theoretical sex-obsessed nymphomaniac (another questionable concept, but bear with me) confined in solitary and thus unable to copulate truly be chaste?  I suspect the answer is no.  What about the soft confinement of living in a small town where her parents would hear everything?  What about the effects of indoctrination?  What about the softer confinement of peer pressure?  Where does environment end and individual choice begin?

    It's true that I am not able to come up with any plausible scenario wherein a girl who engages in voluntary sexual relations with double-digit numbers of suitors over the course of two months is not what is broadly termed "slutty."  But to reduce human behavior to a simple matter of numbers is a very dangerous proposition.  At the very least, the implication - that numbers can tell us everything - is one we should be wary of.

November 29, 2008

  • Live in fear

    MooncatBlue and NDM posted in real time about shoppers trampling a Walmart worker.  I'm saddened but not surprised.  That's just how people are - they assume the worst can't happen, and then it does, and then they're all "I didn't mean it!"  Of course you didn't.  You weren't taking the worst possible outcome seriously.

    People are going to bill this as "a horrific accident."  Please.  The act of breaking down the door and surging forward was no accident.  It's true that the killing was not planned, but that hardly makes it an accident.  You know what's an accident? A man takes a hike and an avalanche buries him.  No planning, no thought, no human cause.  This was not an accident; it was reckless endangerment of human life for a small gain.  It happens every day when people cut us off in traffic, or when a diner cuts corners and doesn't wash cutlery properly, or when a ridiculously sick and contagious person goes on an airplane flight because they don't want to pay the fees to reschedule everything.  This just happened to be the one time someone actually died from it.

    They're also going to say things like "no one could have known."  Bullshit.  The human body is subject to physics and I feel entirely confident in saying that a 34-year-old man trampled to death was in fact done in by brute physical force.  At the scale of human interaction, physics is entirely predictable.  People could have known easily if they had wanted to know.  "No one cared enough to think for however long it would take to realize it" is more like it.

    "But it's so cooomplicated to worry about things all the time!"

    Yeah.  Welcome to grown-up life.

November 28, 2008

  • Facts of life

    I always view the necessity of telling someone the facts of life with a certain dread.

    "I don't regret it - but it's sad anyway
    Now we're both dead and scared of the black
    This life of games and diligent trust
    It's the things we do or the things we must"
    - Crystal Castles, 'Vanished'

    For some reason I get the confident types.  I get the people who face the thousand petty corruptions of daily life and proudly beam that they have gazed into the abyss, that they have seen the face of true evil.  Maybe they have, in a sense.  Maybe that is the real horror and evil of life, that our day-to-day doings are small and crooked and over a grand scale they add up to be worse than the myriad blasphemies and atrocities we have no names for. 

    All I know is that I am continually seeing people with this grotesquely cavalier, "What's the worst that could happen?" attitude.  It doesn't even disgust me; it alarms me.  I understand that a lot of people have had the ability - through looks, charm, money, or connections - to avoid consequences in life.  But there are some things that can't be so easily deflected.  For some things, when your shield slips and the trouble touches you, it's over.  Not only is that a problem for you, it's a problem for others, because for some twisted reason the same people who are light on responsibility are big on others doing the cleanup. 

    Possibly this is because no one who creates these problems sees what cleanup entails.  "Murder will out," it is said.  But before there's any blood speaking from stones or conscience-driven confessions or anything else, there is the simple and stark physical reality of a large sack of blood and guts rendered suddenly immobile and leaking.  In shows it's all very nice and clean; the hero decapitates the villain and he dissolves into a pyrotechnic display, or stakes a vampire and it turns into ash and blows away.  I look at the suggestion that violence will solve problems in my daily life with disdain not just because most people don't need to be maimed, but also because the cleanup is a problem of horrific proportions.  And unlike movies and TV shows, in real life we are characters who clean up our own messes - or if we don't, we have to deal with even bigger messes later on.

    The vast majority of people have never thought this through.  They are so cavalier, so smug about it.  I know why.  It's because they are safe in their minds.  They never progress beyond talk, so they have no connection to the reality that they so casually suggest.  They've probably never gotten into a single fight as an adult, let alone had to contemplate what I could cruelly and ironically call a two-body problem.  It's become par for the course to sneak in a few sins to lighten up a conversation.  Black humour is edgy, right?  It's cool, right?  Consequences are for people who aren't stars, and baby, we are action heroes, and we will live forever.  I don't know how many of these jokers are going to still be cool about it when people leaving in black bags becomes a very real possibility.  A friend of mine who frequented some pretty seedy places remarked after a bad night that "The feeling of having a gun pointed at you is not actually explainable in terms of something else.  It is not like anything else; it is having a gun pointed at you."

    So if you are reading this, and you recognize yourself even a bit, to you I say: this is life.  Start owning up to your own actions and wishes and yes, even your own stray thoughts.  If you're going to suggest something outrageous, at least understand what you're suggesting.  If you're going to talk big, at least resolve in some tiny corner of your mind to walk big should it become absolutely necessary.  You don't have to go so far as to do it - I'd prefer that you don't.  But it would be great if there was a connection between what comes out and what your brain has actually dwelled upon for some time. It would be great if there was some small measure of sincerity and resolve behind what comes out of your mouth.

    It's a small request.  Think on it.  For me.