Statisticians will tell you that correlation never by itself implies causality. Sciforums.com had an exchange between several members on the use of the term "asking for it" as shorthand for "it is statistically more likely that . . . "
Six pages in, Tiassa posted an inspired reply that I thought I would repost here in case any of us are confused about the difference between statistics and causality, as it pertains to rape. To set the stage, another member has just suggested that there is no real difference between saying a girl "was asking for it" and "was engaging in behavior that increased the likelihood of her being assaulted." He suggested that a woman should cover up in public just as she would when eating a lobster. Here is the response:
The thing is that a woman is not a car, and a man is not the weather. The car does not get the random urge to get up and go dancing. The weather does not single out anyone to rain on. And . . . the lobster is dead. If it squirts you when you crack it open, I can promise you the thing wasn't thinking, "He's not wearing a bib! He wants me to squirt my hot stuff all over him!"
I personally would take a different tack in explaining this, and approach it from the angle of rights. Either a woman does have the freedom to dress as she chooses, or she does not. In modern societies we tend to be proud of the fact that people can say virtually anything and wear virtually anything. Now, if she has total freedom to dress as she chooses, then we cannot turn around and say that dressing provocatively means she was "asking for it" and that sexual assault is an acceptable punishment. Failure to defend her simply because she was dressed for a hot date is tantamount to saying she doesn't really have the right to dress as she pleases. In fact, we have a term for that: extrajudicial punishment.
Does the metaphor break down? The freedom we speak of is not complete. "You can't yell 'fire' in a crowded theater," as the saying goes. But here again the legal punishment for the equivalent act already exists and is very specific: public indecency statutes call for police to arrest offenders, cover them up, cite and/or fine them, and transport them out of sight. By no means is state-sanctioned rape part of this. Accepting anything more extreme as punishment is counter to the rule of law - a topic that ironically tends to be very near and dear to those who tend to use language such as "asking for it."
Let us consider two different decency violations. If a male student streaking naked in celebration of some college event were to be accosted by a man and brutally raped, it would be on every major news channel. Our nation would rise up in shock and horror, and there would be demands that the "immoral homosexuals" be purged from among us. But if - when - a female student is brutally raped while wearing skimpy clothing to some college event, the same national level of outrage does not manifest towards all rapists. They are all violations of the law, but the questions bear asking: why do we not see rapists dragged behind trucks until they fall apart, or tied to a fence and beaten until unrecognizable? Where are the calls for a great purge of rapists, the vast rallies against them, the "stay strong with sports" bulletin boards? Where are the pastors thundering intolerance, hatred, and brimstone from the pulpit at them? Does the issue not merit at least equal screen time?
I would think, as it is a far more widespread issue, it requires more attention - and yet we are so accepting of rape that we ignore it, or even blame the victim. Rape is so commonplace that it does not occasion surprise or comment. Does this not bother people? Does it only matter when our daughters, our mothers, our sisters, our friends or lovers are in danger? Let me pull something relevant out that is statistically valid: people who have committed sexual violence will commit it again. This is true whether they are targeting women, men, or children. You want to protect your loved ones?
"Put the evil away from among you."

Recent Comments