July 2, 2008

July 1, 2008

  • Futile Query

    "It's like being plugged into a big battery or something."

    "Wait. No.  It's not because you are in love.  It's because you are following your destiny again.  For several years you were off, disconnected from fate, and now that you're doing the right thing and putting effort into it it's working again for you.  You are once again riding the currents of circumstance in the proper direction.  This has restored your cosmic senses, righted your imbalance."

    "Could we maybe make this a little less epic?"

June 30, 2008

  • Tips For Lecture Attendees

    Here are a few things every lay person should consider before attending a scientific lecture.

    Do not ask, "My religion holds X is true; does science uphold this?"  There really is no good answer to that; if there were, history would be different.

    Do not stand up and talk about how the government is bad/good/relevant, unless it truly is relevant to the actual study being discussed (and maybe not even then.)

    Do not ask the scientists present to confirm or deny your conspiracy theories.

    Do not invoke the speaker's lengthy credentials and then say, "With your credentials, it should be possible to . . . " when you yourself have no grasp of what is possible.  Scientists are neither gods nor magicians.

    Do not hold the scientist accountable for the government's actions.

    Do not hold the government accountable for the scientist's actions.

    There are thousands of scientific articles published yearly in each major field of study.  Do not act like it is a huge travesty for someone to not have heard of one particular article, when everyone agrees that article is not widely recognized.

    Any sentence that begins with, "Well, why don't we put a scientist on every street corner and - " does not deserve to be completed.  Believe it or not, there really are not enough scientists to put a scientist with relevant training in charge of every little thing.

    Any plan that requires the cooperation of over thirty governments and over 500 billion USD in operating funds is probably not going to be taken seriously.  Particularly if you came up with it in the last 30 seconds. Even more so if you have no background in the field.

    Do not repeatedly demand simple, unqualified answers after both the scientist speaking and the scientists in the audience have tried to simplify thirty years of research into a single paragraph for you.

    A lot of data collection and analysis went into producing the graphs you are looking over.  Do not demand graphs for everything, as if someone could just walk over and hit "Print" to obtain the graphs you want.

    With love,

    Someone who can tell that you do not have a scientific background.

June 29, 2008

June 28, 2008

  • Amarisa vs. moritheil (By request)

    Bear with me a moment.  When you quote someone exactly word-for-word, even assuming it might be out of context, can it be called "putting words in their mouth?"  Can it be accurately portrayed as a misquotation?

    The comments section here heated up suddenly, and I was accused of changing someone else's words to suit my purposes.  I found this strange, since I only quoted them to provide a jumping-off point, and they were not changed in the least.  I apologized anyway, since I felt that was expected of me.  It was not a great apology, but let's be frank - I didn't really owe one at all.  I did not feel responsible for things that were not my fault, and I truly did not understand the meltdown-level reaction it provoked*. 

    Then my interlocutor resorted to insults, reasoning that only a deficiency in reading comprehension could account for my failure to magically and perfectly understand her intent.  Given the fact that this mad tirade was begun over a word-for-word quotation that she insisted was a horrible misquotation, the reader will perhaps understand if I suggest that this argument is less than compelling to me.  The entire thing is ludicrous, but like a grisly accident, I don't feel particularly compelled to let it slide without pointing it out.

    I am reproducing the relevant text below in case deletions or edits occur.  Since I have been insulted without doing anything to warrant it, I may include some unkind commentary.  I should earn that insult, after all, no?

    PS: it has been communicated to me that Amarisa has blogged about it, after her self-imposed stop.  Our drama runneth over.  Feel free to stop by and leave both of us comments.



    From what
    I've seen, abortions are performed mainly for two reasons: lack of
    respect for human life, or lack of resources.
    There are, for example,
    plenty of financially (and otherwise) secure women who already "have
    enough" children so they get an abortion as a backup to failed
    contraception. Then there are those women who lack the support they
    need, whether it be emotional, familial, or financial, to feel
    confident enough to continue their pregnancies. There are many other
    scenarios, but those are just two that I have seen personally.

    I
    think abortion is unconstitutional--we all have the right to life,
    liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. I am convinced of this because
    of science. At conception a unique human life is created. Sperm and egg
    unite to form a unique DNA pattern that will never occur again. We need
    to work to have the unborn recognized for what they are--completely
    human--and we need to work to have more options readily available to
    those who are unprepared for pregnancy.

    Posted 6/27/2008 12:05 AM by Amarisa


    @Amarisa - 

    "Abortions are performed mainly for two reasons: lack of respect for human life, or lack of resources."

    The central problem is, what price is appropriate to place on a human life?

    Posted 6/27/2008 12:20 AM by  moritheil


    @moritheil - 


    Please
    do not misquote me. I chose my words carefully and for a purpose. Your
    misquote makes it seem as if I consider myself an authority, and that
    there are ONLY two reasons why women seek abortions--neither of which
    was communicated by my original comment.
    Posted 6/27/2008 2:30 PM by Amarisa

    @Amarisa - 


    That is actually what your original comment communicated to me. I am
    sorry that you feel that I misquoted you. Thank you for clarifying.

    Posted 6/27/2008 3:29 PM by  moritheil 


    @moritheil - 

    Well,
    I do not have control over whether or not the people who read what I
    write are actually good readers who are capable of picking up on
    subtlety in language.

    And I do not "feel" that I was misquoted.
    It is a fact. Normally, I would let something like this go, but what I
    wrote concerns such an important and emotionally-charged topic that I
    wish for the specificity of my language to remain unaltered. I hate
    having "words put in my mouth."

    I will now drop the subject.

    Posted 6/27/2008 3:47 PM by Amarisa

    *"Oh no!  Someone might misunderstand me on the Internet! Surely this is of greater concern and better warrants my attention than mass rape and genocide in Africa,
    thousands dying in the Middle East, or over a million people in the US
    and
    China displaced by flooding.  What if (gasp) I was actually unable to
    defend what I said to someone?  That might mean I could eventually have
    to retract something as being wrong!  And on abortion, no less, which is a topic that millions of people will have to individually decide on!  How will they fare without being able to rely on my guiding light instead of deciding for themselves?"

    Okay, NOW I've put words in your
    mouth.  Feel free to continue to argue for the importance of some
    trifling nuance in your admittedly ill-informed (i.e. non-expert)
    comment on abortion, one of thousands on the topic on the Internet, and
    thereby validate my putting these words in.  As for me?  The essence of your post was conveyed in my quote.  In apologizing I was being kind to the point of untruth, but I see now that casting pearls before swine in this fashion is unwise.

    @Amarisa - 


    Okay, you are getting totally bent out of shape over a direct quotation
    that is word-for-word what you wrote. That is, by definition, neither a
    "misquotation" nor "putting words in your mouth." In English, the
    burden is on the writer to communicate effectively. If you do not like
    having something attributed to you, don't write it. Your apparent
    inability to portray subtleties accurately (if that is what it is, and
    not simply changing your mind) does not equate to an inability of any
    given reader to grasp subtleties when they are properly portrayed.

    Also,
    taking the last word and passive-aggressively insisting that you will
    drop it? Classy. We weren't even originally at cross-purposes here; you
    just chose to randomly take offense at someone quoting you.

    I'd hate to see what you would do if you were ever interviewed for an article.

    Posted 6/27/2008 4:49 PM by moritheil

June 27, 2008

June 26, 2008

June 25, 2008

  • Idle Question

    Jew and non-jew kissing in the entryway of a synagogue following a wedding they attended inside: tacky, tasteless, cute, funny, ironic, sweet, ill-advised, or what?

    Does your answer change at all if people were forced to file past them?

June 24, 2008

  • Embodied

    They were the three ladies of Greek myth, bearers of violence and dispensers of vengeance.  One bore the items.  One moved like a fish through the currents of society.  One danced and so easily held the attentions of everyone.

    I was watching them and it was punishment.