June 28, 2008

  • Amarisa vs. moritheil (By request)

    Bear with me a moment.  When you quote someone exactly word-for-word, even assuming it might be out of context, can it be called "putting words in their mouth?"  Can it be accurately portrayed as a misquotation?

    The comments section here heated up suddenly, and I was accused of changing someone else's words to suit my purposes.  I found this strange, since I only quoted them to provide a jumping-off point, and they were not changed in the least.  I apologized anyway, since I felt that was expected of me.  It was not a great apology, but let's be frank - I didn't really owe one at all.  I did not feel responsible for things that were not my fault, and I truly did not understand the meltdown-level reaction it provoked*. 

    Then my interlocutor resorted to insults, reasoning that only a deficiency in reading comprehension could account for my failure to magically and perfectly understand her intent.  Given the fact that this mad tirade was begun over a word-for-word quotation that she insisted was a horrible misquotation, the reader will perhaps understand if I suggest that this argument is less than compelling to me.  The entire thing is ludicrous, but like a grisly accident, I don't feel particularly compelled to let it slide without pointing it out.

    I am reproducing the relevant text below in case deletions or edits occur.  Since I have been insulted without doing anything to warrant it, I may include some unkind commentary.  I should earn that insult, after all, no?

    PS: it has been communicated to me that Amarisa has blogged about it, after her self-imposed stop.  Our drama runneth over.  Feel free to stop by and leave both of us comments.



    From what
    I've seen, abortions are performed mainly for two reasons: lack of
    respect for human life, or lack of resources.
    There are, for example,
    plenty of financially (and otherwise) secure women who already "have
    enough" children so they get an abortion as a backup to failed
    contraception. Then there are those women who lack the support they
    need, whether it be emotional, familial, or financial, to feel
    confident enough to continue their pregnancies. There are many other
    scenarios, but those are just two that I have seen personally.

    I
    think abortion is unconstitutional--we all have the right to life,
    liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. I am convinced of this because
    of science. At conception a unique human life is created. Sperm and egg
    unite to form a unique DNA pattern that will never occur again. We need
    to work to have the unborn recognized for what they are--completely
    human--and we need to work to have more options readily available to
    those who are unprepared for pregnancy.

    Posted 6/27/2008 12:05 AM by Amarisa


    @Amarisa - 

    "Abortions are performed mainly for two reasons: lack of respect for human life, or lack of resources."

    The central problem is, what price is appropriate to place on a human life?

    Posted 6/27/2008 12:20 AM by  moritheil


    @moritheil - 


    Please
    do not misquote me. I chose my words carefully and for a purpose. Your
    misquote makes it seem as if I consider myself an authority, and that
    there are ONLY two reasons why women seek abortions--neither of which
    was communicated by my original comment.
    Posted 6/27/2008 2:30 PM by Amarisa

    @Amarisa - 


    That is actually what your original comment communicated to me. I am
    sorry that you feel that I misquoted you. Thank you for clarifying.

    Posted 6/27/2008 3:29 PM by  moritheil 


    @moritheil - 

    Well,
    I do not have control over whether or not the people who read what I
    write are actually good readers who are capable of picking up on
    subtlety in language.

    And I do not "feel" that I was misquoted.
    It is a fact. Normally, I would let something like this go, but what I
    wrote concerns such an important and emotionally-charged topic that I
    wish for the specificity of my language to remain unaltered. I hate
    having "words put in my mouth."

    I will now drop the subject.

    Posted 6/27/2008 3:47 PM by Amarisa

    *"Oh no!  Someone might misunderstand me on the Internet! Surely this is of greater concern and better warrants my attention than mass rape and genocide in Africa,
    thousands dying in the Middle East, or over a million people in the US
    and
    China displaced by flooding.  What if (gasp) I was actually unable to
    defend what I said to someone?  That might mean I could eventually have
    to retract something as being wrong!  And on abortion, no less, which is a topic that millions of people will have to individually decide on!  How will they fare without being able to rely on my guiding light instead of deciding for themselves?"

    Okay, NOW I've put words in your
    mouth.  Feel free to continue to argue for the importance of some
    trifling nuance in your admittedly ill-informed (i.e. non-expert)
    comment on abortion, one of thousands on the topic on the Internet, and
    thereby validate my putting these words in.  As for me?  The essence of your post was conveyed in my quote.  In apologizing I was being kind to the point of untruth, but I see now that casting pearls before swine in this fashion is unwise.

    @Amarisa - 


    Okay, you are getting totally bent out of shape over a direct quotation
    that is word-for-word what you wrote. That is, by definition, neither a
    "misquotation" nor "putting words in your mouth." In English, the
    burden is on the writer to communicate effectively. If you do not like
    having something attributed to you, don't write it. Your apparent
    inability to portray subtleties accurately (if that is what it is, and
    not simply changing your mind) does not equate to an inability of any
    given reader to grasp subtleties when they are properly portrayed.

    Also,
    taking the last word and passive-aggressively insisting that you will
    drop it? Classy. We weren't even originally at cross-purposes here; you
    just chose to randomly take offense at someone quoting you.

    I'd hate to see what you would do if you were ever interviewed for an article.

    Posted 6/27/2008 4:49 PM by moritheil

Comments (25)

  • Misquote my ass.

    And she even has the audacity to go so far as calling it fact?

  • Misquotes and all aside, that was a rather rapid escalation of hostilities right there. Almost entertaining, except to think that people actually got angry.

  • I lost a close friend because of an argument like that. Except ours was about religion.
    The ironic part? We're both Muslim. She is religious, I am not.

    She refused to speak to me because she took my words and twisted them into an excuse to break off our friendship. We haven't spoken in at least 3 months. I refused to apologize... I guess my pride wouldn't let me. I had nothing to apologize for.

    It happens...

  • thank you =) and btw. I love reading your weblogss, always keeps me entertained =)

    `hiskewlgurl

  • ryc: it's true the argument has been around for a long time.. thought that concept was old, cliche, no longer discussed, but i was rather surprised to see people still blaming video games.. it's amazing how mankind always likes to point fingers..

  • Is this how real wars start?

  • casting pearls is a mixed bag, for realz. hi mori.

  • A direct quote that was misquoted...  A divine contradiction bathed in total irony...

  • Like I said, the majority of people don't have a clue as to what they're talking about anyway.. :P

    I am now concocting, in my head, how many ways one could misquote that particular quote. It's rather funny.

  • How was that misquoted? It's directly from her comment. And she calls it a "fact" that you misquoted her.

    You win, in my eyes.

  • This is why people go to war; peace is boring.
    Now if you'll excuse me I think I'll go pick a fight with someone random.

  • The nerve of some people. Really. I think you won the argument, though.

  • Wow. I am SO confused. How was that a misquotation?
    To put it in the words of a Fox commentator: THAT WAS PRACTICALLY VERBATIM

    rofl

  • maybe she can say it was out of context like you admitted... but to shriek her head off claiming that it is a MISQUOTE and that her declaration is a FACT?! she's whacked! you literally quoted her! as in the whole verbatim thing! you know what? i think if she won't stop, bring this up to the higher authorities (i.e. dan or drakonskyr)... the xanga public can decide if you misquoted her or whatnot. honestly, she just couldn't take the heat that the ammo used against her were her own creation. it was grand (not just big or kind or magnanimous) of you to apologize... she could've just let it go. you win... hands down.

  • Wow, I can hardly believe a person could be so ignorant as to what qualifies as a misquote. It sounds like Amarisa is frustrated that you didn't fully understand whatever meaning she had inside her head--although you interpreted the words she wrote accurately indeed. I think you are right, and you responded to her appropriately.

  • A misquote?

    Can I please have the luxury of informing her as to what a misquote means?

  • @akhalde - 

    The deed, she is done.

  • You rock Morithiel! You handled the situation like an adult! I would be very happy to be your servant :") ♪♫ Sounds to me like she is the one twisting and putting words in your mouth haha. She said, from what she has seen, and what she thinks. Putting your thoughts online here means that you should be open to the criticism of the online xanga community (even though you didn't seem to criticize at all). You have the right to interpret what she says or ask for clarification. Knowing one of my close friends, she would have just pointed out that line

    "We need to work to have the unborn recognized for what they are--completely human--and we need to work to have more options readily available to those who are unprepared for pregnancy."

    and said something funky like, "NO! Don't make me stand up for what you believe in, do it yourself! You should work and make options readily available to specific people who are unprepared for pregnancies, and give specific solutions." etc.. or something like that. I use to do the same, "we this," "we that." *shudders* when i go back and re-read my entries and notice they would make me feel good but than like you said somewhere ages ago, innovation speaks more than words? blah i butchered the saying but hopefully it comes out right *cough* XD.

  • The post and comments speak for themselves.

    And no, not that I am inclined to agree with you because this is your weblog afterall, and you're the one I've been avidly reading so far, it is rather simple-common sense.

    Subtleties aside, it is one's self-worth that sparks most unnecessary arguments.

  • Back to the original topic, what about women who have abortions for health reasons? If carrying a child is going to endager your life, do we force you, under her scheme of things, to do so? At what point does the mother's life become more or less valuable than a fetus of unproven viability?

    What about the cost of raising a child that you don't want? I think that Miss High and Mighty, I need to dictate to the world what to think, needs to get her butt over to a group foster home and deal with the children that are 1) already here and 2) largely rejected by society. I think it's critical that she gets a good dose of reality shoved up her nose before she starts advocating bringing more unwanted children into the world.

  • My first reaction to Amarisa's post was: okay, you have your opinion which is fine. I won't go into details about why I disagree with it or anything

    My reaction to your response had I been Amarisa was that it seemed that you were merely making a comment as to which one is supposed to do on a blogging website.

    My reaction to you quoting her was that you couldn't have gotten more direct in quoting her. Not only was it word-for-word, her intention is clearly stated in the sentence. Say what you mean, I took it the same way you did.

    My reaction to her freaking out was WTF@?@!! misquoted? are you...I mean, do you know how to read?

    I hate when people take offense over everything. She has an opinion and thats fine, now I think she needs to calm down a little bit.

  • This is a bear trap.  A lot of xanga is this: setting bait for a rage-filled dramatic arguement with people you will never have to meet in real life.  I think the lesson here is that people are passionate to the point of retardation about this issue.  You can tell by the way someone writes that they are salivating for the chance to fight and be "outraged" at someone else.  You could have quoted her entire post verbatim and she would have found a way to be pissed off about it.  It has nothing to do with you misquoting her or not, she just wants to show you that she's completely offended by your worldview.  I find that this is how they do it: they lash out at people who have a differing perspective and then get offended when you stand up for what you've said.  Throw some Jesus in there, some food from Cracker Barrel, an American flag or two, and you've got yourself a travesty.  It is amusing as hell that you are smarter than her, but I don't know if this does one bit of good.  As long as you like masturbation, you're welcome to engage "dialogue" with these people, because masturbation is all it is.  Nothing useful or productive about it.

  • Okay, I went over to this post and read what this chick had to say.  Abortion politics aside for a sec, why is it that a bible-thumpin' Cletus can be so pro-life, and yet so quick to fry a person in the death chamber?  This who "sanctity of life" arguement has some obvious holes.  Did you check out the site she referenced for Abortion Horror Show?  The page is riddled with typos.  There's an obviously intelligent, objective perspective there.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *