August 23, 2008

  • Tools

    There are conceptual tools that don't really carry well from one field to another.  Line noise, for example, doesn't really exist for biologists, but it's a crucial concern for physicists and engineers.  Overall, I recognize and accept that there are a lot of tools out there that I know nothing of, and there are a lot of ways of slicing reality that I may never have practice with.  That's okay.

    What irks me is when I bring someone in on a discussion of something, and to really get at the matter, I have to ask that they use my conceptual tools - and they refuse.  Really, why is this so difficult?

    I had an hour-long conversation with a friend of mine who insists that all communication is conscious and verbal.  I seriously don't know how someone could do that with a straight face.  After his repeated protestations, I tried shifting the topic, trying to get him to play along and assume for the sake of this conversation that I had gotten information from extraconscious communication, but like a pit bull, he refused to let go.  In the end I got no helpful advice from him because he refuses to acknowledge that information can exist that he doesn't access.  Apparently the implications would be too earth-shattering for him.

    I mean, I know as a musician he's not exactly knocking down the Chaos Math courses, but is it really so hard to admit that there could exist information that you just haven't been paying attention to?

August 22, 2008

August 21, 2008

  • Laughter of Nana

    She laughed.  It was a good sound, free of context, purely and perfectly human.  Not like the tinkling of chimes or the whispering of wind or any of the Windflowers' laughs.

    It wasn't going well.  It was all I could do, and I discovered too late that there was too much I didn't know, but it was my one chance and I couldn't screw it up.  I had to go along.  There was no waiting.  So from the start it was rush, rush, rush.  I was certain at the end there would be rushing too.

    Understand this: the really big choice was never quite mine to make.  I made it, all right, but it was such that doing anything else would have been madness.  I am not so calculated, I am not so composed, that I could see this in front of me and not take it.  An empty-handed swordsman who could lay his hands on the masterwork of a smith would do so instantly.  A nomad in the desert who saw a sweet water well would certainly drink.

    Choose, urged the voice.  Choose, screamed the sky.  Choose, wrote a finger in the ashes of my name.

    And I chose.

    Now there was only the waiting, the reacting, the seeing how things played out.  And I had chosen, and it wasn't going well.  Or it had, really, but I could see it slipping away.  Bit by bit.  It was a subtle thing, insidious - but even as I got comfortable with it, it seemed to be shifting, changing. I could not look down the road and know with absolute and clear certainty that it would still be there.  And that worried me.

    It was about that time I started drinking.

    [Reminder: all original content on this site is copyright 2004-2008. All rights reserved.]

August 20, 2008

  • Questions And Theology

    Twotothefightingeighthpower asked a while back, "Is murder bad only because [G-d] decrees it to be so, or is it bad of its own accord?" 

    I will try to answer this in a way such that the mental framework of belief is evident, since without it the answer is likely to be unhelpful.  To the believer this is like asking if the sun is bright because it has hydrogen, or if it is bright because its gravity is not so immense that the light cannot escape.  It is a choice that misapprehends the situation.  For the sun to be bright it is necessary that it has hydrogen for fusion, and that it not be so massive that light cannot escape, and above all that fusion, the process that produces the light, takes place. 

    How are things things?  Or rather, how do things exist?  Do they exist under their own power?  Are they wholly their own entities?  The rationalist says, in the tradition of Occam, "Yes, of course; why should things be any different?"  But that is not how the Christian sees the world.  Things exist at the sufferance of the Creator; relationships likewise exist at the sufferance of the Creator.  If murder is inherently evil then it follows that the Creator has decreed against it; if the Creator has declared that murder is evil, it will follow that the nature of murder will be evil.  So the "only" qualifier is misleading, as well as the "of its own accord."  In this case it is generally accepted among Christians that the Creator has decreed that murder is not to be done, and since as a general principle disobeying the Creator is evil, murder is evil.

    The principle, by the way, is hardly hidden: in Genesis, they make a point of explaining that as soon as the Creator spoke, reality altered itself.  Let me repeat that: what the Creator says has effects upon reality.  Therefore it is at the least misunderstanding the situation to suppose that the Creator saying something is comparable to a human saying something.  Something different is going on.

    Now, you certainly can say, "I don't accept all of that."  But the moment you do, we are no longer engaging in a discussion about the Christian deity.  We are instead talking about some sort of crippled, Gnostic deity, or some sort of familiar spirit peddled under the guise of Christianity, or something else - in short, some sort of mental construct that does not have all the crucial features of the Christian deity.  And when we discuss this similar-looking construct, it will be no surprise that you will arrive at a conclusion that does not equate it with the Christian deity.  By its nature the Christian system admits no defeat while the discussion is within the system.  This is something that you either can accept or cannot accept.

    In answering this I am fully aware that a portion of my answer will probably be taken as silly by some readers.  It is not possible for a conversation between a believer and a nonbeliever to avoid what appear to be ludicrous answers at some point, because the realities that they hold in their minds are structured so differently.  Nevertheless, the question is asked honestly, and here addressed.

August 19, 2008

  • Dictatorship Revealed

    [01:04] moritheil: I had an interesting debate with someone.
    [01:04] moritheil: He posits that the fundamental material needs are the most important, and may preclude civil liberties.
    [01:05] moritheil: "You can't eat the right to vote," he argues.
    [01:05] moritheil: My argument is - what amount of goods is a fair trade for an intangible?
    [01:05] moritheil: Rights are basically intangibles.  Love, peace, security, happiness - these are also intangibles.
    [01:06] moritheil: For how much food should we trade love?  Or for how much money, since the two are equivalent?
    [01:06] Terenar: That's a good question.  I posit that there is actually a tradeoff, since people have sold themselves into slavery when that was an option.
    [01:07] Terenar: Unfortunately the ratio is hard to calculate if it's even calculable.
    [01:07] Terenar: I would actually side with the person who thinks material needs take priority over civil liberties, but from a slightly different angle.
    [01:08] Terenar: Civil liberties are a government construct, and so can only exist when there is a functioning government to enforce them.
    [01:08] Terenar: When a society is so poor or so insecure that a functioning government strong enough to enforce civil liberties can't keep power, civil liberties won't stick.
    [01:09] moritheil: And if the government is plenty strong, but disinclined to grant liberties?
    [01:09] moritheil: Or, if the government is the one brokering the exchange?
    [01:12] Terenar: Then there's a problem.  And I can't say I know the answer.  IIRC, the Taiwanese government eventually decided it wasn't worth the effort to stay in power against its people, but I doubt that's inevitable.
    [01:15] Terenar: Isn't the problem with dictatorships and economic development that if a dictator can hit on a working formula, the country can progress more rapidly than a democracy with inconstant policies, but it's much easier (and rather more common) for the dictator to instead put the country into a deep hole?
    [01:16] moritheil: Basically the problem is that there has to be a feedback mechanism.
    [01:16] moritheil: But the dictator can circumvent it quite easily.
    [01:16] moritheil: And this is inevitably far easier to accomplish than actually solving the country's problems.

August 18, 2008

  • Christianity and Justice

    Factionalism makes me despair over the future of Christianity.

    Jesus, with one notable exception, was not factional.  People were sick, their consciences worried them, and they had bills to pay.  He understood this.  His action was therefore to go out amongst the worst of humanity and try to show them love.  In doing this he was being what we would today call "liberal," but he was also acting in harmony with traditional principles amongst the Jewish: Welcome the stranger.  Keep people alive.  Life is worth more than just money. 

    The one exception that Jesus made was in refusing to treat a non-Jew until she begged him, and it is an open question how much of that story was a deliberate act of setting up a contrast and the theological basis for Christianity.

    The politics of modern Christianity, as practiced in the USA, are phenomenally detrimental to the message of Christianity itself.  Look at the politicians scramble to make voters feel that they are in tune with the desires of fundamentalist Christians and you will understand precisely what I mean.  Nominally Christian politicians are now concerned with advancing a specific agenda over the protests of others (and in some cases, actually to their perceived detriment!)  I do not wish to enter into long arguments about how much this actually will hurt people, because this is not the crux of the problem: the problem I speak of is one of perception.

    The instant anything is politicized in America it becomes just another faction.  Hundreds of noble causes -  immigration reform, campaign reform, public housing reform, relief for the poor, reducing the spread of harmful drugs, and many more - have all fallen by the wayside as soon as they entered politics.  As soon as something becomes a political issue, it becomes defanged and incapable of causing real change.  Instead it is now a political counter, a token - it has limited value as a set number of points in an ongoing game between two opposed hierarchies.  Politicians will pay it lip service for as long as they need to, and render it as little actual service as possible.

    Nor are Xangans immune to the corrosive nature of factionalism.  SwordandSacrifice, by all accounts a sincere Christian and patriotic American, cannot see that forcing a man to change his Arabic-language T-shirt for a plain one is as much a violation of free speech as forbidding the printing of Bibles.  Now, he is not unintelligent - far from it.  Why would he fail to see the similarities?  Factionalism provides the answer.  That the Arab man is silenced is not an issue for him, since he admits that he identifies him as the enemy.  But when a Christian evangelical campaign is threatened, suddenly this is cause for cry and hue.  Suddenly this is a problem that cannot be ignored.

    Sir, I have a quote for you from a popular Christian thinker: "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."  If you truly wish Christianity to flourish, it cannot be seen to be self-aggrandizing.  It cannot win by war, by conquest, by trickery.  It must deal fairly and evenly with all, and win over people on the basis of legitimate merit. It must do this - or fail.

    I do not think you wish it to fail.

August 17, 2008

August 16, 2008

  • Humour: You Get It Or You Don't

    There is a certain degree of comprehension which I find separates some readers from others.  I speak not of base reading comprehension, but of ability to grasp that vague and undefinable quality we call humour.  My own most recent experience with the gap came in the Baz parody I submitted ('Indulge'), but that relied heavily on context: either you were aware of the original and therefore knew to look for the differences, or you were unaware of the original, or worst of all, you were aware of the original but lacked the ability to notice differences at all, and thus failed to grasp that this was a parody reconstruction.  Whether or not it is truly funny is, actually, secondary; the main point is that the differences serve to highlight important points of divergence.  Parody is always a critique of the original.

    The series where I have tested my readers the most with regard to humour comprehension is my Xanga MetaContest.  Frankly, the idea of a recursive contest amongst contests is a blistering parody of the very conceit of having a Xanga contest.  However, like all satire, it isn't any good unless played to the hilt, and this is where I apparently lost a lot of people.  Even in judge selection, when I personally chose a number of people who
    I assumed would get it, there was one potential judge who turned out
    not to be a good fit.  A girl invited to judge raised a number of practical questions, which immediately told me that she didn't get it. 

    To be sure, if your mind is on autopilot, you will miss satire.  It is less a matter of logical deduction and more a matter of pure insight.  Practical considerations, however, have little place in it.  Jonathan Swift's classic suggestion that we eat babies has many of the marks of a serious proposition written in his time; the main clue that he is not serious is the very fact that it is a treatise on the economic benefits of cannibalism.  Stephen Colbert is, to this day, thought of by some particularly uninformed viewers as being a serious reporter, not a parody of right-wing commentators.  It takes absurdity and the recognition of that absurdity - and that alone - to elevate a piece of work to satire.

    I find myself uneasy about the recent prominence of satiric material that incorporates "tells."  These kinds of works start out absurd, but then acknowledge their absurdity, and then challenge the reader to respond.  To me, that rather misses the point: one should never admit in the piece itself that one is being absurd.  The fourth wall is clearly damaged here, and to what effect?  I don't find it any funnier to have a comedian who can't stop laughing in the middle of his joke because he thinks it's so great, and that is basically what is going on in such works. 

    If I go on a mock kids' show and say, "Heyyyyyy kids, jump off bridges!" while grinning and giving a thumbs' up, that's satire.  I reveal the emptiness of the show's conceit and the absurdity of its premise by switching a presumably reasonable rejoinder ("Hey kids, buy my product!") for an unreasonable one ("Fling yourself to your deaths!")  It only gets funnier if I take it seriously and play off of it for the rest of the show ("And while you're plummeting down to certain doom, why not enjoy one of my Frosty Fruit Drinks?  Frosty: it gives meaning to life.")  A third step might be to incorporate a visual gag of a fat child falling, drink in hand, grinning ear-to-ear while the ground rushes up.  Conversely, I lose most of the humour potential if I instead immediately follow my initial statement about bridges with, "I don't really mean that."  In order to do satire properly, there either has to be no admission that you are not serious, or the admission has to be far separated from the act (i.e. 10 minutes later, the credits include a legal disclaimer.)  To admit the truth in the middle of the act is to destroy the act.

    Sheesh.  Why don't you guys know this stuff already?  What clown college did you people go to?

August 15, 2008

  • Michael Pt 2

    The chains are loose, and you might imagine, from just watching, that they are not restrictive, but you would be wrong.  It is their weight, it is their cold touch, it is their clinking that form the real chains.  Cold iron keeps the trickiest of the fair folk pent, but I am not fair and I will not use tricks.

    A voice speaks, and I am reminded of an injunction I cannot follow.  Truthfully I always doubted I could, though I tried nonetheless.  Some things - some curses - run in the blood, and how could we expect this one to not touch me when it had a hand in my making?

    I shift my arms, slowly.  I have not decided to break these chains.  How many?  I run my eyes down innumerable silver links, myriad children arm-in-arm for a better world.  How many strictures do I need?  How many chains until it is enough?

August 14, 2008

  • Simple Logic

    I normally don't traffic in featured questions, but this one is so badly posed that it utterly fails to get the writer thinking of his or her own experiences.  I will apply logic to show you how absurd it is and how experience does not enter into it.  The question is, "Is it true that what does not kill you makes you stronger?"

    1.  It is possible for something to not make you stronger (obvious, but a necessary statement.)
    2.  Not all changes kill you.
    3.  These two sets overlap (something can both not make you stronger and not kill you.)

    Therefore, the proposition that "what does not kill you makes you stronger" must be untrue.  What I am saying is that as posited it automatically must be untrue - even before you need to think of experiences to disprove it on some practical level, it is already untrue on a fundamental, conceptual level.  It's that bad.

    Now stop thinking that Nietzsche is such a badass and giving yourself boners imagining that your pain and suffering are there to transform you into something better.  If you suffer, you suffer.  If you improve, you improve.  That one should be necessary for the other is a lie that has misused us for eons.

    I just destroyed this Featured Question!