There is a certain degree of comprehension which I find separates some readers from others. I speak not of base reading comprehension, but of ability to grasp that vague and undefinable quality we call humour. My own most recent experience with the gap came in the Baz parody I submitted ('Indulge'), but that relied heavily on context: either you were aware of the original and therefore knew to look for the differences, or you were unaware of the original, or worst of all, you were aware of the original but lacked the ability to notice differences at all, and thus failed to grasp that this was a parody reconstruction. Whether or not it is truly funny is, actually, secondary; the main point is that the differences serve to highlight important points of divergence. Parody is always a critique of the original.
The series where I have tested my readers the most with regard to humour comprehension is my Xanga MetaContest. Frankly, the idea of a recursive contest amongst contests is a blistering parody of the very conceit of having a Xanga contest. However, like all satire, it isn't any good unless played to the hilt, and this is where I apparently lost a lot of people. Even in judge selection, when I personally chose a number of people who
I assumed would get it, there was one potential judge who turned out
not to be a good fit. A girl invited to judge raised a number of practical questions, which immediately told me that she didn't get it.
To be sure, if your mind is on autopilot, you will miss satire. It is less a matter of logical deduction and more a matter of pure insight. Practical considerations, however, have little place in it. Jonathan Swift's classic suggestion that we eat babies has many of the marks of a serious proposition written in his time; the main clue that he is not serious is the very fact that it is a treatise on the economic benefits of cannibalism. Stephen Colbert is, to this day, thought of by some particularly uninformed viewers as being a serious reporter, not a parody of right-wing commentators. It takes absurdity and the recognition of that absurdity - and that alone - to elevate a piece of work to satire.
I find myself uneasy about the recent prominence of satiric material that incorporates "tells." These kinds of works start out absurd, but then acknowledge their absurdity, and then challenge the reader to respond. To me, that rather misses the point: one should never admit in the piece itself that one is being absurd. The fourth wall is clearly damaged here, and to what effect? I don't find it any funnier to have a comedian who can't stop laughing in the middle of his joke because he thinks it's so great, and that is basically what is going on in such works.
If I go on a mock kids' show and say, "Heyyyyyy kids, jump off bridges!" while grinning and giving a thumbs' up, that's satire. I reveal the emptiness of the show's conceit and the absurdity of its premise by switching a presumably reasonable rejoinder ("Hey kids, buy my product!") for an unreasonable one ("Fling yourself to your deaths!") It only gets funnier if I take it seriously and play off of it for the rest of the show ("And while you're plummeting down to certain doom, why not enjoy one of my Frosty Fruit Drinks? Frosty: it gives meaning to life.") A third step might be to incorporate a visual gag of a fat child falling, drink in hand, grinning ear-to-ear while the ground rushes up. Conversely, I lose most of the humour potential if I instead immediately follow my initial statement about bridges with, "I don't really mean that." In order to do satire properly, there either has to be no admission that you are not serious, or the admission has to be far separated from the act (i.e. 10 minutes later, the credits include a legal disclaimer.) To admit the truth in the middle of the act is to destroy the act.
Sheesh. Why don't you guys know this stuff already? What clown college did you people go to?
Recent Comments