August 23, 2008

  • Tools

    There are conceptual tools that don't really carry well from one field to another.  Line noise, for example, doesn't really exist for biologists, but it's a crucial concern for physicists and engineers.  Overall, I recognize and accept that there are a lot of tools out there that I know nothing of, and there are a lot of ways of slicing reality that I may never have practice with.  That's okay.

    What irks me is when I bring someone in on a discussion of something, and to really get at the matter, I have to ask that they use my conceptual tools - and they refuse.  Really, why is this so difficult?

    I had an hour-long conversation with a friend of mine who insists that all communication is conscious and verbal.  I seriously don't know how someone could do that with a straight face.  After his repeated protestations, I tried shifting the topic, trying to get him to play along and assume for the sake of this conversation that I had gotten information from extraconscious communication, but like a pit bull, he refused to let go.  In the end I got no helpful advice from him because he refuses to acknowledge that information can exist that he doesn't access.  Apparently the implications would be too earth-shattering for him.

    I mean, I know as a musician he's not exactly knocking down the Chaos Math courses, but is it really so hard to admit that there could exist information that you just haven't been paying attention to?

Comments (11)

  • For some people, yes. It's really important that they hold on to their universe, and keep it the way it is. Le sigh. Sorry you had to have one of those conversations.

  • to pretend like we know the way it IS.. is such a blemish on the essense of humanity. when people tell me the way it just is, I cringe. not just a little.

  • musicians tend to be interesting. but they also tend to give me gas.

  • Apparently for him, unfortunately yes.

  • musicians like most other self orientated job descriptions tend to have larger than usual egos!

  • I suppose the state of your agitation was not something communicated verbally or consciously? Looks like he limited himself to the tools he (thought he) had...

  • He must be a horrible date, if he thinks the only form of communication is verbal.  Footsies FTW!

  • Not all communication is verbal. Your friend seems like the kinds of person who hates to be wrong..

    A lot of my communication is done with facial expressions and hand gestures. I barely NEED to be vocal about what I'm talking about.

    There is always information that no one knows. That you'll never know. It's impossible to know everything because we're taught certain things from specific points of view. What you learn depends on who's the observer.Bah, I make no sense.

    -Kunoichi

  • It's just generally hard for people to acknowledge that there are other tools out there to use. Why else do therapists make money, really? Have you tried using your friend's tools? Isn't music itself an example of non-verbal communication, much of which is also subconscious? More than anything you wrote, this is the point that makes me suspicious of the true openness of your friend, as well as the true depth of his musician-ness, because I feel like I'm stating the obvious here. The really really obvious. I mean, musician and mathematician? Aren't these two fields quite deeply linked and ripe for conversation of exactly the sort you were trying to have? Um... duh?

  • it's difficult to grasp that the world is bigger than what you can handle...

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *