May 16, 2009

  • The Marriage Spectrum

    An interesting post from trunthepaige raises the issue of marriage being one of a spectrum of relationship types.  The question that naturally follows is, should our society, which prides itself on tolerance for different lifestyles, take a page from the ancients and start acknowledging many different types of relationships?

    Paige raises the issue of Greek society, which accepted not only homosexual and heterosexual relationships, but also different sorts of relationships between men and women: wives were entrusted with the family finances and with raising the kids; dalliances were formed with heterae for love, and temple prostitutes were used for alleviation of lusts.  It was a complex system, unlike the modern ideal that compresses marriage, love, and lust together in a personal union.

    Of course Greek society was infamously patriarchal, as men went to war and thus had control over society.  Were we to adapt Greek ways in today's post-feminist environment, it would go without saying that we would have some gender equality.  We would see women with husbands raising the family, dandies for love, and call boys used for the alleviation of lusts.

    Would this brave new world bring us happiness?

May 15, 2009

May 14, 2009

  • Orientalism at its finest?

    Check out the comments section here.

    Cold Onlookers Encourage Man to Kill Himself

    Many commenters saw this behavior as essentially Chinese:

    "Well, you have to first realize that this happened in China. Land of a billion people. 1 guy dead doesn't matter, especially if he wants to off himself. Only in America does everybody kick and scream and make a big fuss because some criminal was shot by a cop at a transit station. Anywhere else in the world the cop would have been a hero for taking a criminal off the streets."

    "The Chinese there were just mean people."

    "Having been to China 4 times with my wife, a PRC citizen, I've noticed somewhat of a different mentality in the Chinese. Perhaps it is because there are so many people there or perhaps it is the result of the rampant human rights abuses they suffer at the hand of their government, but they seem to value human life less than I. The government notoriously cares little about their people and this seems to permeate the society. I'm not sure of relevance to this incident."

    "Godless they are."

    Some others did not:

    "Yet I have absolutely no doubt in my mind that this could happen just as easily in America if some dumbass was threatening to jump off the Brooklyn bridge, halting the traffic."

    "China has nothing on Seattle, at least. Even the city bus drivers were taunting the jumper. Mob mentality at its finest."

    So, what do you think?  Is this behavior uniquely Chinese?

May 13, 2009

  • It's an attack

    Without meaning to, I got in an interesting argument with someone over this article I posted a link to.

    This person was a liberal atheist who argued that the outrage over revelations that the CIA conducted chemical experiments on children was disingenuous.  The CIA, went her argument, exists to do morally unjustifiable things in the name of expediency.  Therefore no matter what they do, we should never be shocked or appalled.  I didn't agree, and I thought this reasoning was fascinating given that the speaker was an outspoken lesbian, strongly in favor of personal liberties.  I would have thought that she would be against the government performing experiments on people without their consent.

    It came out that her uncle, whom she has fond memories of, was a CIA spook, and she bristled when she heard someone criticizing the CIA.  "My uncle was a good man," she wrote, as if daring me to say otherwise.

    That is really at the crux of discussions of morality and standards: due to our tendency to interpret these issues in the ways most familiar to us, such conversations almost invariably wind up being about other things.

    What is justice, exactly? Is it adherence to a set of rules?  Is it protecting "good people" and making "evil people" suffer? Ask five people and you might get ten answers.  But here this conversation veered away from the abstract concept of justice and into a deeply personal realm: family.  Many powerful emotional statements turned up: He was a good man.  He loved his family and his country.  He did what he thought was necessary to keep us safe.

    Morality in real life is not a simple transaction.  "To murder is wrong.  To harm others is wrong.  You would not like these things done to you; do not do them to others."  So runs the simple logic that we are taught as children.  But in the real world, morality is only ever applied at these convoluted collisions of family, loyalty, love, and duty.  It is only in such a tangled mess that a moral judgment becomes necessary.

    Now, I never appointed myself the judge of her uncle or of any individual agent, or even the CIA as a whole.  I merely posted the article with the observation that creating a secret agency with carte blanche to conduct experiments on its own people is, and ought to be, troubling to the average person.  But we can very easily see here the human tendency to react to anything which borders on criticism of loved ones as an attack.  And once that attack is seen - even if the intent was not there - discussion of the issues becomes impossible.

    How many other arguments are bogged down by this sort of thing?  Moral principles interpreted as an "attack" on one's habits? Environmental issues seen as an "attack" on one's "way of life?"  Scientific inquiry interpreted as an "attack" on one's religion?

May 12, 2009

May 11, 2009

  • Capoeira

    A young man in the cord belt and white pants wiped a trickle of sweat off his brow. "Get ready for dance fighting!" 

    The blows came, quick like lightning, but when the dust cleared, the distinguished-looking gentleman in tophat and cloak stood unfazed. The ground rippled.

    "Ah, but how can you dance," he smirked, "when the earth is turning?"

May 10, 2009

May 9, 2009

  • Initiate drama

    [00:17] moritheil: I've been thinking of mi1kandcerea1's post about guys disappearing after relationships end.
    [00:17] moritheil: A ton of girls posted up about how hurtful that is.
    [00:20] moritheil: They acted like it's some kind of betrayal on the guy's part
    [00:20] moritheil: and I'm like, WHY?
    [00:20] moritheil: You don't want him.
    [00:20] moritheil: You reject him from the core of your being. That's what a breakup is.
    [00:20] moritheil: Why is he supposed to stick around and ask you how your day was?
    [00:20] moritheil: Hell, if you're broken up, why do you even want him around at all?
    [00:20] onlyfr33b33: it's that whole narcissistic neediness that is instilled in our culture
    [00:20] onlyfr33b33: maybe...
    [00:21] moritheil: I'm like, "Don't you people think about this crap before you break up?"
    [00:21] moritheil: I mean, if it sucks so much to have him gone, maybe, I don't know, don't kick him out?
    [00:24] moritheil: It's kind of like explaining to people why locking yourself out of your car is undesirable if you want to continue to drive it.

May 8, 2009

  • Mix Tape

    This is what I was listening to earlier.

    1. 'Here I am' - Special D
    2. 'Bookmark Ahead' - Strike Witches ED
    3. 'Adelaide' - Anberlin
    4. 'Tom's Diner (DNA remix)' - Suzanne Vega
    5. 'Inevitable' - Anberlin
    6. 'Dismantle. Repair' - Anberlin
    7. 'Potential Breakup Song' - Aly and AJ
    8. 'Music' - AAA
    9. In My Arms (Bronleewe and Bose Remix) - Plumb
    10. 'Beds are Burning' - Novaspace
    11. 'Shiawase no Iro' - Aa Megami-Sama OP
    12. Love is War - Miku Hatsune
    13. 'Look at Us' - Sarina Paris
    14. 'Sakuranbo' - Ai Otsuka
    15. 'Your Hand in Mine' - Explosions in the Sky
    16. 'Shoutout' - Jet Set Radio Future
    17. 'Hitohira no Hanabira' - Stereo Pony

May 7, 2009

  • Bully Pulpit

    Suggestivetongue wrote an entry about word choice and how hurtful words can be.  Overall, I agree with her, but there's something I have to point out: explaining the potential consequences of cruelty to a bully is counterproductive. At best, they don't care.  More likely, you'll only encourage them.

    We sometimes get this bizarre idea that all people are good, charitable folk at heart.  We are trained to assume good faith, because the illusion of good faith is essential to the proper working of society.  However, realistically speaking, nothing could be further from the truth: millions of people die every year because other people can't be bothered to do whatever it would take to help them.  I don't argue that this should discourage us from trying to do productive things, but at the very least it should inform our policies.

    The average bully is lashing out.  Telling them they are hurting others will only bring satisfaction, not remorse.