May 13, 2009

  • It’s an attack

    Without meaning to, I got in an interesting argument with someone over this article I posted a link to.

    This person was a liberal atheist who argued that the outrage over revelations that the CIA conducted chemical experiments on children was disingenuous.  The CIA, went her argument, exists to do morally unjustifiable things in the name of expediency.  Therefore no matter what they do, we should never be shocked or appalled.  I didn’t agree, and I thought this reasoning was fascinating given that the speaker was an outspoken lesbian, strongly in favor of personal liberties.  I would have thought that she would be against the government performing experiments on people without their consent.

    It came out that her uncle, whom she has fond memories of, was a CIA spook, and she bristled when she heard someone criticizing the CIA.  “My uncle was a good man,” she wrote, as if daring me to say otherwise.

    That is really at the crux of discussions of morality and standards: due to our tendency to interpret these issues in the ways most familiar to us, such conversations almost invariably wind up being about other things.

    What is justice, exactly? Is it adherence to a set of rules?  Is it protecting “good people” and making “evil people” suffer? Ask five people and you might get ten answers.  But here this conversation veered away from the abstract concept of justice and into a deeply personal realm: family.  Many powerful emotional statements turned up: He was a good man.  He loved his family and his country.  He did what he thought was necessary to keep us safe.

    Morality in real life is not a simple transaction.  “To murder is wrong.  To harm others is wrong.  You would not like these things done to you; do not do them to others.”  So runs the simple logic that we are taught as children.  But in the real world, morality is only ever applied at these convoluted collisions of family, loyalty, love, and duty.  It is only in such a tangled mess that a moral judgment becomes necessary.

    Now, I never appointed myself the judge of her uncle or of any individual agent, or even the CIA as a whole.  I merely posted the article with the observation that creating a secret agency with carte blanche to conduct experiments on its own people is, and ought to be, troubling to the average person.  But we can very easily see here the human tendency to react to anything which borders on criticism of loved ones as an attack.  And once that attack is seen – even if the intent was not there – discussion of the issues becomes impossible.

    How many other arguments are bogged down by this sort of thing?  Moral principles interpreted as an “attack” on one’s habits? Environmental issues seen as an “attack” on one’s “way of life?”  Scientific inquiry interpreted as an “attack” on one’s religion?

Comments (8)

  • I’m trying to think of something intelligent to respond to this with. Once again, you made me think. Love it, Thanks.

    I suppose that this is why many theories about psychological development put developing a code (I can’t think of a good word other than code) of morality at one of the highest forms of development. I think it was Kohlberg that actually did a theory on moral development, which is divided into 6 stages. The 6th and highest stage is considered “Self-selection of universal principles” or something like that. And it’s apparently a far climb to reach that point, and few people make it.

    It probably has something to do with the fact that people base so much of what the live and do on themselves. Which is normal, and not necessarily selfish, I mean, it is Their life, but it certainly makes one wonder.

  • @Laryssa - 

    Thanks. I think Piaget posited four categories: amorality, simple morality, moral relativism, and a fourth state in which one recognizes ambiguity but nevertheless selects a moral code to follow. Kohlberg expanded these.

  • “creating a secret agency with carte blanche to conduct experiments on its own people is, and ought to be, troubling to the average person.”–Agree.

    I have problems with the word “morality” though. It is one of the most abused words in our vocabulary. It is easy to twist and turn.

  • Excellent post. Experience and personal ties colour everything, all of our reactions.

  • nothing’s ever black and white, and there’s usually some bias in there too

  • Hannelore!

    I don’t really believe in morality, or justice, either. When someone works against the way the rest of the world works, that someone and everything that someone built will be eliminated. We probably won’t see it within our lifetimes, but it always exists on the grand stage of time.

  • it’s hard to be objective about most things when we all have different experiences, levels of maturity, knowledge, and generally NOT the full story. there’s no replacement for wisdom and discretion. i think it’s a learned skill to see someone’s opinion as just that rather than as a judgment on other people.

  • Never let your morals get in the way of doing what is right?

    People like the one you were arguing with tend to be more concrete/rigid in matters in which they are personally involved or ego-involved.  It should make us all reconsider a supposedly reasoned response by examining the assumptions that came first before putting forth such an argument/response.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *