August 2, 2008

  • Deconstructing Sunscreen

    Most of you grasped what I was doing with Baz Lurhmann’s speech pretty quickly.  You may not have done so using the terms I use – words like “deconstruction,” “recontextualization,” and “structural analysis” – but you could tell what was going on.  I will admit that this is not always the case with my writing.  Earlier works, such as ”To Rut or Not To Rut,” seemed to have at least two people going “WTF” for every one who got it.

    ‘Sunscreen’ was a wildly popular hit in the 90s.  I think it’s important that when something like this happens – a middle-aged man rambling about life turning into something people actually want to listen to – we as thinkers look at what is happening.  Is it the content of the speech, the structure, or the message that’s effective?

    Really there is no good way to test this.  We have the text, though, so we can simply alter it and see what happens.  Now, ‘Sunscreen’ is about the beauty and wonder of life.  It is not written by a pessimist and it is not written by a minimalist.  There is one scientific fact presented in the speech, and that is that wearing sunscreen is good for you. That fact is so absurdly unhelpful in terms of most of the decisions we make in life that it forms the basis of the humor.

    And that’s really a profound statement about science.  For the most part it doesn’t give you tailor-made personal advice you can always use.  Sunscreen really is about the extent of that.  Nor does science deal in absolutes from the perspective of humanity – sure, it says chaos wins and even black holes boil away in the long run, but all of that is so far removed from the human life span that none of it seems to matter.  ‘Sunscreen’ is really on some level about how useless science itself is for the big decisions and how there is no certainty in life.

    Having established this message, we can toy with it.  We can take the message of ’Sunscreen,’ which is on the surface innocuous, and replace it with something entirely different like a call to hedonism. Guess what? That’s still popular. At 100 comments, about 4 did not approve, and those 4 all cited not seeing credit to Baz as their reason (presumably they missed the Baz tag.)

    Maybe they’re right, though.  Maybe this constitutes a dangerous flirtation with the forces of cultural appropriation, non-prominent attribution, and unoriginality.  Maybe this is a step down the slippery slope to becoming Puffy Combs or Fatboy Slim.  What can I say to that?

    Indulge.

Comments (10)

  • It’s good that you tagged “Baz”… and I saw it :) I loved that song because there are a lot of things in it that I agree with.

  • haha I thought you were gonna talk about sunscreen as in the stuff you rub on your skin.

  • ~ nods ~ yeah… WTF?

    lol.

  • i saw a girl on the train i wanted to rub some on. lol

  • ZOMG I SAW THE SUNSCREEN SPEACH! i think, i could have sworn thats it because its been in my mind the whole times ive been reading this.

  • i’m pretty sure i have a new boyfriend.

    i’m pretty sure he’s amazing.

  • this is some cerebral stuff, man.  quite an interesting sociological experiment.  i recognized the parallel to Baz Luhrmann’s speech based on its textual structure, but what resounded with me was the irony in your juxtaposition of the “call to hedonism” with a gentle warning against promiscuity.  not sure if that was purposeful.

    but that’s a great statement about science.  it’s a religion based upon theories that seemingly have not been debunked.  and even that scientific fact about sunscreen might one day prove to be false when some researcher writes a paper on the carcinogenic effects of the chemicals included in sunscreen.

  • @davidian - 

    It’s not really a religion at all. You could call it a philosophy. (I get uneasy when people think of science as merely a replacement religion rather than a different way of looking at things from religion.)

    I am glad that you grasped it.

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *