Axis of doom asks, "Are Asians the Model Minority?"
I'm not trying to shoot the messenger, but please, think about what you're saying before you perpetuate a term.
For Axis, the term implies financial success. All good and well. But then, why not ask, "Are Asians financially successful?" What he fails to recognize in glibly passing on this catchphrase is the assumption behind the idea that there can be any such thing as a model minority.
What do people mean when they refer to a "model minority"? For that matter, what is "model behavior"?
Bluntly, model behavior is when other people behave how you want them to.
What is it that drives America? Money, perhaps, on a practical level. Ideologically, it's Liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Self-determination is probably the most sacred, the most instinctive American right. So what is it that fuels this entire idea that some minorities are "model" and some minorities are not? It's fundamentally an attempt to fit people, with their own needs, fears, and dreams, into some sort of predetermined box so that they can be of use to the one making the judgment. Why should it be okay for the majority to do that? It's not.
In fact, I seem to recall that the Pilgrims objected to being treated that way - which is why America as we know it exists. Did they come to America because they wanted to fit in? No! They came to seek out a life of their own. Why should we, their inheritors by spirit if not by blood, seek to bend others to our will? Can we not accept that others, too, come to America because they do not fit in elsewhere and seek a place of their own?
Minorities are people. Do people exist just so that you can use them as you see fit? The entire business of classifying minorities as more or less "model" based on willingness to put up with arbitrary demands (or more precisely, the majority's inappropriate application of their own cultural standards) is dehumanizing, and I lament the fact that it continues to be acceptable in public discourse. It just shows how far we have yet to go in actually embracing the idea of human rights.
Recent Comments