There is nothing immoral about fantasy, as long as no one is harmed. Specific fantasies may be intensely unpopular, and make people uncomfortable due to similarity to acts in which people would be harmed - but just as we do not regard people as murderers for making movies or games with victimless, simulated murder, it would be ridiculous to hold someone in the same light as a rapist for producing a victimless, simulated rape (whether that rape occurs due to age or other conditions.) While law is not morality, fantasy is moral for the same reason it is legal - it's all in the realm of thought. To argue otherwise is to confuse simulation with reality, to confuse morality with emotion, or to confuse mere cultural conventions with morality.
Let's examine that last bit:
That trips many people up. Consider: is slavery morally wrong in a society where most people own slaves and nobody thinks much of it? If so, then cultural conventions have nothing to do with morality. If, on the other hand, cultural conventions do dictate morality, then slavery is morally right as long as it's an established practice.


Recent Comments